When Seeking Pre-Trial Receivership For Solvent Companies Less May Be More

Receivers may be appointed where a company isorders places the business at greater risk for
insolvent, in danger of becoming insolvent, winding up itsappointment of a receiver.
affairs or a judgment debtor. However, did you knowSuch pre-trial appointments can be a powerful tool to
that prior to trial a plaintiff may seek a court-appointedreign in renegade management, ensure the business is
receiver for a solvent, on-going business?not run into the ground pending trial and preserve
Receivers are primarily a statutory creation. Californiaassets for proper business advantage and/or post-trial
offers a broad "catch-all" provision permitting receiverscollection.
when necessary to preserve the property or rights ofHowever, a plaintiff who has an ownership interest in
any party. More specifically, receivers may bethe on-going business should also consider the
appointed where property or funds are in danger ofdownside. News of the appointment might negatively
being lost, removed or materially injured. Theseimpact customer interest and supplier alliances. A
statutes come to the aid of plaintiffs when a solvent,receiver unfamiliar with the business or industry could
on-going business is involved.even damage the company and impair its day-to-day
For example, a court may appoint a pre-trial receiveroperations. Moreover, the cost of a receiver can be
for a solvent, on-going concern when managementsignificant, and may be borne by the business and/or
dominating the corporation is accused ofthe plaintiff.
misappropriation, fraud, mismanagement, self-dealing,Thus, when a receiver is sought for a solvent, on-going
failure to share profits or failure to account. In suchconcern, the idea that "less is more" may be a sage
cases, a court is justified in appointing a disinterestedstrategy, and a plaintiff may find it advantageous to
party as a receiver to control the business, preserveseek a receiver for limited purposes. For example, a
its assets and protect the rights of the complainingplaintiff might request that a receiver merely "oversee"
stockholders or other owners pending trial.existing management rather than "replace" existing
Courts are also willing to appoint a pre-trial receivermanagement, that a receiver merely take over limited
where some aspect of the business is beingtasks (i.e., an accounting), or that a receiver merely
conducted illegally, particularly if the business could losepreserve particular assets pending trial.
its license to operate or is exposed to third-partyTailoring a receiver's involvement to a plaintiff's actual
litigation.needs may not only increase the likelihood a receiver
Receivers are particularly appropriate wherewill be appointed for a solvent, on-going concern, but
defendants are likely to refuse to follow court ordersmay also offer the best long term benefits for both
or injunctions. Thus, a track record of violating courtthe plaintiff and business entity.